CO129-190 - Governor Hennessy - 1880 [10-12] — Page 390

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

377

Mr. Gibbons, and take the management of the houses out of Mr. Gibbons' hands.

Whether in this order I was right or wrong and whether what I did was right or wrong, are questions which I leave to the testimony of Mr. Mossop and Mr. Wotton though. This is a nice question not for His Excellency the Governor, but for the Privy Council.

Mr. Gibbons is necessarily ignorant of the facts and state of the case of re Kustace whatever may be the state of his knowledge of the very peculiar international law applicable to that case. Mr. Gibbons wrote without knowledge when he made a statement contrary to that part in his letter to you of 29 September.

I have taken great pains to understand the international law applicable and state positively that what I laid down in the one case is entirely consistent with the decision in the other case.

I therefore state that what Mr. Gibbons has said as to my actions in the two cases is contrary to fact.

And now I come at length to the gravamen of Mr. Gibbons' letter - his charge is that I hold that I have a right, that it is my duty to make him personally liable.


387

This I acted contrary to what I had laid down in the case of Pustau's Bankruptcy. I who do know the facts are different from my decision in re Austau.

Page 390

Page 391

Edit History

2026-05-22 02:28:07 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
377 Mr. Gibbons, and take the management of the houses out of Mr. Gibbons' hands. Whether in this order I was right or wrong and whether what I did was right or wrong, are questions which I leave to the testimony of Mr. Mossop and Mr. Wotton though. This is a nice question not for His Excellency the Governor, but for the Privy Council. Mr. Gibbons is necessarily ignorant of the facts and state of the case of re Kustace whatever may be the state of his knowledge of the very peculiar international law applicable to that case. Mr. Gibbons wrote without knowledge when he made a statement contrary to that part in his letter to you of 29 September. I have taken great pains to understand the international law applicable and state positively that what I laid down in the one case is entirely consistent with the decision in the other case. I therefore state that what Mr. Gibbons has said as to my actions in the two cases is contrary to fact. And now I come at length to the gravamen of Mr. Gibbons' letter - his charge is that I hold that I have a right, that it is my duty to make him personally liable. 387 This I acted contrary to what I had laid down in the case of Pustau's Bankruptcy. I who do know the facts are different from my decision in re Austau. Page 390 Page 391
Baseline (Original)
377 Mr. Gibbons, and take the management Mr. Gibbons hands. of the houses out of. Whether in this order I was sight or wrong and whether what I did was f 387 that in directing a meeting of creditors to appoint a breditors' Assignée to relieve him in hg a This I'acted contrary ng what I had laid down in the to case_of -of Pustau's Bankruptcy. I who do know- different from mmy decision in re Austau the are fact t questions which I leave to the testimony of Mr. Mossop and Ir. Wotton though. This is a nice question not for His Excellency the Governor, but for the Perry Council mr bibbons is necessarily ignorant of the facts state re kustace whatever may the be the of his knowledge of very peculiar international law applicable to that case. Mr. Gibbons wrote without knowledge. when he made a statement contrary to part in his better to you of 29 September. that & herave takem great pains to understand the international law applicable state positively that what I laid down" in the one caRL is entirely consistent with decision in the other case Ir ming I therefore Mr. Gibbons has said state that what actions as to to my in the two cases is contrary to fact- And now I come at length to the gravarmen of het Sibbons letter his charge is that I hold that I have a right that it is my duty to make him personally liable ec. Page 390Page 391
2026-05-22 02:28:07 · Baseline
View content

377

Mr. Gibbons, and take the

management

Mr. Gibbons hands.

of the houses out of.

Whether in this order I was sight or

wrong

and whether what I did was

f

387

that in directing a meeting of creditors to appoint a breditors' Assignée to relieve him in hg a This I'acted contrary

ng

what I had laid down in the

to

case_of

-of

Pustau's Bankruptcy. I who do know-

different from

mmy

decision in re

Austau

the

are

fact t

questions which I leave to the

testimony of Mr. Mossop

and Ir. Wotton

though. This is a nice question not for His Excellency the Governor, but for the Perry Council

mr bibbons is necessarily ignorant of

the

facts

state

re kustace whatever may

the

be the

of

his knowledge of

very peculiar international law applicable to that case. Mr. Gibbons wrote without knowledge.

when he made a statement contrary

to

part in his better to you of 29 September.

that

& herave takem

great pains to

understand the international law

applicable state positively that what I

laid down" in the

one caRL

is entirely

consistent with decision in the

other

case

Ir

ming

I therefore

Mr. Gibbons has said

state that what

actions

as to

to my

in the two cases is contrary to fact-

And now I come at length to the gravarmen of het Sibbons letter his charge is that I hold that I have a right that

it is my duty to make him personally

liable

ec.

Page 390Page 391

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.